Payton Pritchard: Start or Bench?

The Payton Pritchard Conundrum: Boston's Starting Point Guard Puzzle

When the Boston Celtics moved Payton Pritchard into the starting lineup following Jrue Holiday's departure, it signaled a new chapter for the 2025 Sixth Man of the Year. But with Jayson Tatum sidelined due to an Achilles injury, Pritchard's expanded role has sparked intense debate in Celtics Nation: Should he remain in the starting five or return to his familiar bench role?

Expanded Responsibilities, Evolving Performance

Pritchard has embraced his elevated position with impressive statistics. Currently averaging 16.2 points, 4.4 rebounds, and 4.9 assists per game, the Oregon native has shown remarkable versatility. His shooting percentages – 32.9% from beyond the arc and 43.9% overall – reflect an adjusting sharpshooter facing increased defensive attention. As Celtics Wire notes, Pritchard's importance to the team "can't be ignored," particularly with Tatum out. He's now third on the team in touches per game, demonstrating his expanded playmaking responsibilities.

"Pritchard has developed into one of the most reliable sharpshooting guards in the NBA, is a proven contributor both off the bench and as a starter and has begun to flourish as a playmaker."
— Celtics Wire Analysis

The Bench vs. Start Debate

Despite his solid production, questions linger about Pritchard's fit as a starter. Some analysts, including those on WEEI's "Jones and Keefe" show, suggest the Celtics might be better served moving Pritchard back to the bench with Anfernee Simons taking over starting duties. The argument hinges on Pritchard's proven success as a Sixth Man of the Year and the potential need for different skillsets at the starting position.

However, Pritchard's recent performance tells a nuanced story. While he faced shooting struggles against the Timberwolves (9 points on 4-14 shooting, including 1-8 from deep), his resilience stands out. As RotoWire reports, he responded by attacking the rim and mid-range more aggressively – a sign of his adaptability. This evolution in his game shows Pritchard's determination to succeed regardless of his role.

What's Ahead for Pritchard and the Celtics?

As the Celtics navigate Tatum's absence, Pritchard's role will remain fluid. His ability to balance perimeter shooting with aggressive rim attacks could ultimately determine the team's success. Whether he starts or comes off the bench, Pritchard's "importance to the Celtics can't be ignored" – especially as he continues to develop into a more complete playmaker.

The coaching staff faces a strategic balancing act: maximizing Pritchard's scoring punch while ensuring optimal chemistry in the starting lineup. With his shooting percentages expected to climb as he adjusts, Pritchard may yet prove that his starting role is the right fit for Boston's championship aspirations.